Improving Productivity – an Ardent Requirement

 I worked for around 9 years in Gulf Countries and have good idea about the productivity of human resource in these countries. In India; for block-work masonry, we talk about 70 to 80 blocks per mason per day (6-7 sqm/mason/day) as productivity; whereas in Gulf it’s about 200 to 230 blocks per mason per day (16-18 Sqm/mason/day). Similarly, for cement plastering in India, the productivity is like 10-12 Sqm per mason per day but in Gulf its 25-30 sqm/mason/day. I can give several such examples where it can be noticed that the productivity there is 3 to 4 times of that in India.

What, we all should be worried about is that we are falling in to a vicious circle:

Although there are several efforts being taken to improve the overall productivity for the item of work; almost all these efforts are directed towards one of the following:

a)     Mechanization of works: Use of Plant & machinery viz. Cranes / Climbing Platforms

 b)     Changing Materials: Use of Precast Panels for walls, Bigger Size of Tiles/Artificial Marble

 c)     Changing Systems: Peri/Doka Formwork, Self-Climbing Systems

 All of these do need Capital Investment and thus have additional cost, which is balanced out with savings due to faster pace of construction.

Essentially; we are not resolving the core issue of low productivity of human resources hence we are not even trying to come out of the vicious circle. The only way out is to improve productivity of human resources, which will fetch them better wages, improve their living condition, increase their affordability for better nourishment & with improved health, their productivity will rise further.

In my previous article, I wrote about the factors affecting productivity. In this article I am sharing my thoughts for improving the productivity. The factors, that affect the productivity are:

a)     Degree of Mechanization

b)     Skill & Experience of workers

c)     Location, Type & Size of Project

d)     Site Congestion

e)     Atmospheric Conditions (Temperature/Humidity/Rain)

f)      Worker’s Availability

g)     Degree & Level (Skill) of Supervision

h)     Compactness of Schedule/Timeline

i)       Motivation Level

Since I want to be specific about improving productivity for human resources, I am discarding some of the factors with particular reasons behind it:

  • Degree of Mechanization: Cost of Capital Investment is balanced out with savings due to faster pace of Construction. It also reduces the dependency of availability of sufficient number of workers.
  • Location, Type & Size of Project: We do not have any control on the same.
  • Atmospheric Conditions: We do not have any control except providing relief measures.
  • Worker’s Availability: We cannot change until they get attracted because of higher wages.

Barring above, there are several factors, which are in our control and hence several measures can be taken to improve the productivity as explained below:

 

  • Site Congestion: Although design and drawings are beyond control, we can still improve the working area for better ergonomics, safe platforms, better access, clutter free work space and good house-keeping.
  • Degree & Level of Supervision: Increase the degree of supervision to have the checks right from start of work to avoid any errors/mistakes and thereby rework, corrective measures and defect repairs. Improve the Level of Supervision, by providing technical trainings to our supervisors.
  • Compactness of Schedule / Timeline: Remember the Parkinson’s Law – “Tasks expand to fill the time available”. Alter the schedule in such a way that just enough time is allocated to a task or activity. Any buffer or float available will get used and thus will cause reduced productivity. A Compact Schedule will improve productivity. Just as you keep Contingency in Budget, Keep Contingency in Schedule at End not in-between and specifically not in the activity.
  • Skill/Experience of Workers: Provide skill training to workers, this will definitely improve productivity.
  • Motivation: Better working condition, Better living condition, Empathetic Treatment and Training to improve skill motivates the workers. This motivation, when turns into better wages due to improvement in productivity will be self-priming further motivation.

Pandemic or otherwise:

  1. Availability & Skill-Level of workers is worsening
  2. Timelines are squeezed, Buffers are lost
  3. Cash-flow is poor and waning further
  4. Capital Investments are reducing 

I feel, it’s high time for Indian construction industry to take notice and start taking measures to improve the productivity of human resources.

 

ADGP                           www.decodingcm.com/pm-blogs                  https://decodingcm.blogspot.com

 


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Final Part - Construction Planning Simplified

Image
This is the 4 th and final chapter in this series of simplifying construction planning process for the Construction Team Members. The sole purpose of this entire series was to create awareness in Construction Engineers about how vital their contribution is in the planning process. It was essential for them to know the meaning and use of various terms used in planning; various steps of planning & scheduling right from planning to make a plan, Logistics, Methodology, Decomposition of the whole project, Phasing and Zoning etc. and then Sequencing of works. Naturally in all of these steps the experts in construction need to give valuable inputs and contribute. Further for determining the resources and duration for any activity, their data on productivity based on past experience and the difficulty level of works to modify the productivity is indispensable as planner would have much lower exposure as compared to Construction Managers. Overall, any planning is useless if it does not tak
Read more

Construction Planning Simplified - Part 3

Previous 2 chapters were for the construction team wherein I explained some terms of planning in simple language with examples and the vital contribution expected from the construction team. I believe; it deliberated as to why, how & what the construction team should be party to while preparing construction plan and what is in it for them as well as the planner. In this chapter, there are some simple guidelines to both planner and construction team, which must be kept in mind while preparing the construction plan. These guidelines are more for the planners to understand and act, whereas the construction team must insist for the same and support planners. Naturally there is a lot of contribution required from construction team here too. KISS – KEEP IT SHORT & SIMPLE That’s the first & most important principle for any plan. Remember, the construction plan must be understood by the junior most levels in construction team and hence naming any activity, complexity of activ
Read more

Planning to make a Plan

For every project, any deliverable or even for a task one is advised to have a plan. We keep hearing that having a plan in place is like completing 40% of the task. Won’t you agree that even making a plan for the project is also a sub-project/deliverable/task in itself? If it is so, why not have a plan for making a plan? Will it not be a prolific thing to do? Yes! It is always a best approach to make a plan for making a plan. What shall we include, in this plan? Let’s explore.   We should consider to answer the following and document it for future references: 1.       Stages, WBS Elements and Level of Detailing: a)       Do we need a plan for each of the stages? Feasibility stage, Concept Stage, Design Development Stage, Execution Initiation Stage etc. b)       What should be the ‘Work Breakdown Structure’ in various stages? It is preferable to keep the WBS Structure consistent throughout the stages; some WBS elements may not be included in some of the stages e.g., Plan
Read more